top of page

Traffic Impact Assessments in the Philippines: Why They Don't Work

TSE
1 day ago
8 min read

A new condominium, shopping mall, or mixed-use development goes through the permitting process, and more often than not, Local Government Units (LGUs) would require the developer to have Traffic Impact Assessment (TIA) commissioned. Traffic counts are conducted, trips are estimated, intersections are analyzed, and recommendations are written. Depending on the applicable requirements, the report becomes part of the documents evaluated for development approval.


Twenty-five years after Philippine researchers began developing Traffic Impact Assessment (TIA) guidelines, we are still asking whether the reports actually influence development decisions.


New developments induce vehicle traffic and foot traffic.
New developments induce vehicle traffic and foot traffic.

Then what?


Who ensures that the recommended improvements are implemented? Who pays for them? What happens when the development opens and the roads, sidewalks, and public transport services around it cannot accommodate the additional demand? Does anyone go back to the TIA to determine whether its forecasts were accurate?


We have spent years debating how TIAs should be prepared. We should be spending just as much time investigating **what happens after they are approved**.


Twenty-five Years of Research, and We're Still Here

In November 2026, Ian C. Espada and Noriel Christopher C. Tiglao published in the Journal of Engineering, Environment, and Agriculture Research.


The authors examined five Philippine TIA reports prepared between 2018 and 2023 and compared them with ten Australian reports prepared between 2017 and 2024. The differences were difficult to ignore.


None of the five Philippine reports examined proposed intersection geometry improvements or specified how the cost of recommended improvements would be apportioned to developers. The authors also identified inadequate intersection modeling, limited evaluation of mitigation measures, and a failure to assess pedestrian crossing performance.


To be clear, five reports cannot represent every TIA prepared in the country. Nor should intersection widening be the default response to new development. But the findings raise a basic question: Are we assessing transport impacts to manage development, or are we merely producing enough technical documentation to satisfy the permit process?


Traffic and heritage impact assessments--anyone?
Traffic and heritage impact assessments--anyone?

What is particularly frustrating is how familiar these findings are. Back in 2001, a UP National Center for Transportation Studies Foundation (NCTSFI) team, with assistance from JICA, had already developed draft Philippine TIA guidelines.


In 2003, Jose Regin Regidor and Rene Val Teodoro published Institutionalizing Traffic Impact Assessment in the Philippines: Some Issues and Challenges. They warned about the limited technical capacity of local governments to evaluate reports, weak institutional arrangements, and the tendency to accept descriptive traffic reports in place of actual impact assessments.


Two years later, in Traffic Impact Assessment for Sustainable Traffic Management and Transportation Planning in Urban Areas, they documented how developers could understate traffic impacts and attempt to pass responsibility for mitigation to local governments and MMDA.


Interestingly, that 2005 paper also documented a case in which an inadequate assessment contributed to the rejection of a proposed development's Environmental Compliance Certificate (ECC) application. Government scrutiny, when exercised seriously, could influence approval decisions.


By 2011, Francis Villareal and Karl Vergel had published A Case Study on the Adoption of Traffic Impact Fee in the Philippines, examining how developers could contribute proportionately to the transport improvements necessitated by their projects.


So we have had technical guidelines, identified institutional weaknesses, documented cases, and explored financing mechanisms for more than two decades. It would be difficult to argue that the main problem is a lack of research.


Development Creates Impacts. Why Do Taxpayers Inherit the Bill?


Consider what happens when several large developments are approved along a corridor. Each project might submit its own TIA. Each consultant evaluates traffic under a particular set of assumptions. Each report might conclude that the development's additional impact is manageable, perhaps subject to a few recommended traffic management measures. But what happens when all these developments are operating simultaneously?


Who is responsible for assessing their combined effects? And who pays when an intersection needs redesigning, a pedestrian crossing becomes unsafe, or additional public transport capacity is required?

This is where individual project assessments become inadequate substitutes for corridor-level or district-level planning.


Developers understandably want their projects approved. Consultants are commissioned to prepare the required studies. LGUs want investment, employment, and additional economic activity. None of these interests is inherently objectionable.


The regulatory system, however, must be capable of independently determining whether a proposed development imposes additional costs on the transport network and all of its users, and what proportion of those costs should reasonably be borne by the developer.


Villareal and Vergel's 2011 research explored precisely this issue through traffic impact fees. Their work considered a fair-share approach rather than arbitrarily charging the last developer to arrive for all the deficiencies of an already overloaded road. They also proposed mechanisms to improve financial accountability, including earmarking impact-fee revenues for identified transport improvements.


There are legal, administrative, and technical questions that must be resolved before such mechanisms can be widely adopted. But the underlying principle is reasonable:


Developers should not automatically escape responsibility for the additional burdens their projects impose, while taxpayers are left to finance every necessary improvement.

Neither should developers be charged for unrelated infrastructure deficiencies that government ought to address. The distinction requires proper analysis, transparent cost allocation, and enforceable agreements.


A TIA that identifies impacts without establishing responsibility for addressing them is an unfinished planning exercise.


We May Be Asking the Wrong Traffic Questions Anyway


There is another problem with TIA practice that deserves much more criticism. Its traditional analytical framework is heavily concerned with vehicular traffic generation, intersection capacity, volume-to-capacity ratios, vehicle traffic levels of service, and parking. These measures have legitimate uses. But should they determine whether a development is acceptable from a transport planning perspective?


A building can demonstrate tolerable vehicle delays while providing terrible pedestrian access. A development can satisfy parking requirements while encouraging more car trips. An intersection can be widened to improve automobile flow while making it more difficult and dangerous for people to cross.


Example of intersection treatment from Nacto.org.
Example of intersection treatment from Nacto.org.

We could produce an extremely sophisticated traffic simulation and still recommend an intervention that makes the street worse for everyone outside a motor vehicle. This is why simply requiring better traffic modeling software will not solve the problem. We need to reconsider what the assessment is supposed to achieve.


Why should the transport impact of a development be measured predominantly in terms of additional vehicle trips rather than person trips, accessibility, road safety, and demand for public transport?


Why are pedestrian crossing conditions, access to existing PUV routes, loading and unloading arrangements, and walking connections not consistently central to these assessments?


And why should increasing road capacity be treated as an obvious solution when it may reinforce further car dependence and conflict with broader land-use and transport policies?


There is a particular contradiction when cities promote transit-oriented development while retaining development assessment practices that reward abundant parking, road widening, and the preservation of private-vehicle level of service.


We cannot keep promoting compact, walkable, transit-oriented communities in our land-use plans while assessing individual developments as though accommodating more cars were the principal objective.


Perhaps it is time to move beyond the conventional Traffic Impact Assessment toward a more comprehensive Transport Impact Assessment, with explicit consideration of all travel modes, accessibility, safety, and consistency with local transport plans.


The Consultant Cannot Be the Only One Held Accountable


It is easy to blame consultants for weak TIAs. Some reports undoubtedly deserve criticism for their assumptions, methods, and recommendations. But consultants work within a regulatory system.


If an approving authority (usually the LGUs) requires only a report containing traffic counts and capacity calculations, that is what the market will produce. If nobody requires an independently reviewed mitigation plan, a costed implementation schedule, or evidence that approved measures were completed, those elements are unlikely to become standard practice.


The responsibility ultimately extends to the institutions that determine what must be submitted, evaluate its technical adequacy, and decide whether development may proceed. That includes the capacity of LGU planning and engineering offices, the relevant permitting and environmental review authorities, and transport agencies responsible for affected roads. And tools are becoming more accessible for LGUs to work on sound policies and ordinances.


A development approval should not merely recognize that a TIA has been submitted. Where mitigation is necessary, it should establish clear, legally supportable conditions covering the required interventions, responsible parties, funding, completion schedules, and verification procedures. Those conditions should be publicly accessible.


For sufficiently large developments, independent technical review should be possible. Monitoring should continue after the development begins operating, especially where substantial uncertainty exists in the original traffic forecasts.


And if an approved mitigation measure was never implemented, there should be an appropriate mechanism to enforce compliance. Without these arrangements, the TIA risks becoming little more than an expensive attachment to a permit application.


Start by Making the Reports and Commitments Public


Before proposing yet another round of national TIA guidelines, perhaps we should first examine how the existing system performs. Here are some minimum viable actions, LGUs can start doing or answering now:


  1. Rapid Inventory and Baselining. How many TIAs have LGUs approved over the last five years? How many required off-site improvements? What were the developers required to deliver? How many of these improvements were completed, and what happened to traffic conditions after the developments opened?


  2. Make TIA Reports Public. Can anyone outside government access these records? A credible development assessment system should make it possible to trace an intervention from the original forecast to its approval, financing, completion, and evaluation. The public should be able to distinguish among an intervention that was merely recommended, one that became an enforceable approval condition, and one that was actually delivered. Research institutions and civil society organizations can help evaluate these records, but access to the underlying reports and approval conditions is essential.


  3. Enact a Transport-first Framework and Incorporate in LGU Planning and Governance. We should also stop treating each TIA as an isolated study that becomes irrelevant once the project is approved. Its data, forecasts, and recommendations should contribute to the city's continuously updated understanding of its transport network, including cumulative development impacts. A city should become better at planning with every TIA it receives. Instead, we risk commissioning the same surveys, repeating the same assumptions, and rediscovering the same intersection problems every time another development is proposed.


We Don't Need Another Twenty-five Years


Espada and Tiglao's new paper is an important contribution because it brings the discussion back to actual TIA practice. It also reminds us how much unfinished work remains from research undertaken more than two decades ago.


The issue is no longer simply whether Philippine cities should require Traffic Impact Assessments. We need to examine whether TIAs actually influence development decisions, whether they impose reasonable and enforceable obligations, and whether the resulting interventions improve mobility and safety.


A TIA should be capable of changing a development proposal. Where necessary, it should lead to different access arrangements, better pedestrian facilities, public transport improvements, reduced parking provision, redesigned circulation, or other measures that address demonstrated impacts. In some cases, an approving authority may need to reject a proposal whose impacts cannot be acceptably managed. That is what gives an assessment regulatory meaning.


If a development can proceed regardless of whether its transport impacts are adequately addressed, what exactly are we assessing?


And if government cannot tell the public which mitigation measures developers promised, paid for, and completed, perhaps we should stop congratulating ourselves for requiring TIAs and start asking what those requirements have actually accomplished.


References:

  1. Espada, I. C., & Tiglao, N. C. C. (2026). Traffic impact assessment in the Philippines: A gap analysis with Australian practice. Journal of Engineering, Environment, and Agriculture Research, 5. https://doi.org/10.34002/jeear.v5i0.257

  2. Regidor, J. R. F., & Teodoro, R. V. R. (2003). Institutionalizing traffic impact assessment in the Philippines: Some issues and challenges. Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, 5, 3192–3205. https://easts.info/2003journal/papers/3192.pdf

  3. Regidor, J. R. F., & Teodoro, R. V. R. (2005). Traffic impact assessment for sustainable traffic management and transportation planning in urban areas. Proceedings of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, 5, 2342–2351. https://easts.info/on-line/proceedings_05/2342.pdf

  4. Villareal, F. F., & Vergel, K. B. N. (2011). A case study on the adoption of traffic impact fee in the Philippines. Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, 9, 98–113. https://doi.org/10.11175/easts.9.98

 
 

Address

SafeTravelPH Mobility Innovations Organization, Inc.
UP National College of Public Administration and Governance, R.P. Guzman St., University of the Philippines, Diliman, Quezon City, 1101

Inquiries

For any inquiries, questions or recommendations,

​

developer@safetravel.ph

© 2025 by SafeTravelPH Mobility Innovations Organization, Inc.

bottom of page